In an online discussion of magic some years ago, a visitor made the remark that every practitioner hears sooner or later. He was still waiting, he wrote, for someone to conjure up the winning lottery numbers. Like the philosopher's stone, they seemed to elude the high magicians, and if any of it worked the magicians would all be rich. A regular of the forum answered with some heat. He knew people who had won houses, cars, motorcycles and sums of money by magic, he said, and one woman who won competitions for a living. Such work had to be open ended: if you needed money, you had to let it come from anywhere.
I have some sympathy with both of them and agree with neither. Their exchange touches nearly every question I care about, so I want to take it apart slowly, and then answer the question that had started the thread, which was simply why anyone practices magic at all.
The lottery test
Start with the skeptic, because his test is better than it looks and worse than he thinks. It is better because it is clean. The outcome is public, the odds are known, and nobody can argue afterward about whether the result occurred. Most claims made for magic could do with a test half as clear.
It is worse because of what it measures. The chance of matching six numbers drawn from forty nine is about one in fourteen million. Suppose a working doubled your chances. That would be an astonishing effect, far larger than anything a careful practitioner claims, and it would leave you with one chance in seven million. You would never see it. The lottery cannot detect influence. It can only detect omnipotence, and no serious tradition claims that. The Hermetic treatises promise nothing of the kind. Some of the late grimoires do promise treasure, and against those the taunt lands fairly. Against the art this site describes, it tests a claim the art does not make.
Houses and cars
The believer's evidence fails in a different way. I described the habits of memory that inflate a record of success in an earlier essay, and two further points apply here. The first is the missing denominator. Every prize is won by somebody. If a thousand people do a working for a car and one of them wins a car, the winner has a story and the other nine hundred and ninety nine do not. The professional competition winner makes the point for me: as far as I understand the hobby, its devotees enter a very large number of competitions, and a steady rate of wins is what the arithmetic predicts. The second point is that such stories arrive filtered. Nobody telephones a friend to say that the working for the car came to nothing. A collection of successes gathered by word of mouth shows how stories travel, not how often workings succeed.
The advice that the work be open ended deserves more respect than the stories that came with it. As psychology it is sound. A person fixed on one route to what they need sees only that route. A person who has settled the end and left the means open grows alert to every opening, and more often takes one. If practice works partly by changing what we notice and what we do, which is the least disputed thing anyone can say about it, then open ended work is simply good technique.
But it has a price, and the price should be stated. If the result may come from anywhere, then anything good that happens counts as success and nothing counts as failure. The claim has been made safe by being made empty. My own compromise is to be open about the means and exact about the end: leave the route to circumstance, but write down beforehand what will count as success and by what date. That keeps the psychology and keeps the books.
What the tradition claims
Both shared an assumption: that the point of magic is results in the world, and that the only question is whether it delivers them. The tradition says otherwise. The Hermetic treatises describe one aim, the knowledge that changes the knower and returns the mind to the Mind from which it came, and the first treatise calls this the good end of those who have received knowledge. Later writers, from Ficino to the revival, said the same in their own terms. Results along the way are by products, sometimes useful and sometimes welcome, and a magician who works chiefly for them has mistaken the scaffolding for the building. Our pages on what magick is and on the Great Work set this out at more length.
This is not a retreat to safe ground after the outer claims have failed. It is what the texts said long before anyone thought of a lottery.
Reasons that survive the skeptic
Here, then, is my answer to the question that began the thread. These are the reasons to practice that still stand if every claim about the outer world proves false.
- Trained attention and imagination
- A mind that stays where it is put, and can form and hold an image, is useful in every part of life. Daily practice builds both, and the gain can be counted. I have the tallies of my own breath counting going back years.
- A structure for meaning
- The planetary week, the elements, the Tree: whatever their final status, they give a life an order in which to notice things and reflect on them. Most people reflect more with a structure than without one.
- A discipline of record
- Keeping an honest diary of anything for years teaches a person more about their own mind than almost anything else they could do. Magic is the art that insists on it.
- Devotion and wonder
- A hymn at sunrise is a way of attending to the fact that there is a sunrise. Many people need a form for reverence, and this is one of the old ones.
- Curiosity
- Whether anything lies beyond the psychological account is an open question. Careful practice, honestly recorded, is the only way to look into it for oneself. The experiment is a good reason in its own right.
Bad reasons
There are also reasons that do not survive, and it is a kindness to name them. To control other people: this site will not teach it, the Hermetic writers would have called it a corruption, and the attempt corrupts the one who makes it. To escape a life that needs attention: the work is done inside a life, not instead of one. To replace medicine or therapy: magic is a substitute for neither, and anyone who is ill or in distress needs qualified help first. Our page on ethics and safety says this in more detail, and anyone who recognizes one of these motives in themselves should read it before going further.
Keep the books
Practice, then, for what practice reliably gives: attention, structure, honesty, reverence and a question worth pursuing. Do the practical workings too, if you wish, and do them wholeheartedly. But enter each one in your diary with its date, and count them at the end of the year. If the lottery numbers ever come, I shall be glad to hear of it. The column is ruled and waiting.