In 1900 the Hermetic magic of the revival belonged to a few hundred initiates sworn to secrecy. By the end of the century the same material could be bought in any city, in paperback, beside tarot packs, courses and commentaries by the hundred. In between it was reshaped by a prophet, by a handful of gifted popular writers, by the psychology of the unconscious and, late in the day, by the historians. This page follows those changes and asks what they cost.
In brief
- The papers of the orders were published between 1909 and 1940, and a graded curriculum could now be followed by a solitary reader.
- Aleister Crowley founded Thelema, defined magick, and insisted on method and the written record.
- Dion Fortune, Israel Regardie and Paul Foster Case made the Qabalah accessible; Jung gave practitioners a psychological language for symbols.
- After 1960 came the New Age, the tarot boom and chaos magic, and in the universities the serious study of the tradition.
After the orders
The London order founded in 1888 split around 1900, and its successors divided again; the story is told on our page on the occult revival. Its secrecy did not survive the split. Aleister Crowley printed much of its ritual from 1909, and between 1937 and 1940 Israel Regardie published its papers in four volumes. A curriculum that had required sponsorship, admission and examination could now be followed by a solitary reader with a library card. Almost everything else on this page depends on that fact.
Crowley and Thelema
Aleister Crowley (1875 to 1947) was initiated into the London order in 1898 and quarreled with most of its leaders. In April 1904, in Cairo, he wrote down over three days a short text he called The Book of the Law, dictated, he said, by a voice that announced a new age. The philosophy he built on it is called Thelema, from the Greek word for will. Its law is summed up in the phrase do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the law, which had a literary ancestor in the single rule of the imaginary abbey of Theleme in Rabelais.
The phrase is easily misread as permission to do as one likes. Crowley meant the opposite. Will in his sense is not whim or appetite but the true will: the course that expresses what a person most deeply is, to be discovered by long training and then followed against every distraction. Every man and every woman, the book says, is a star, and Crowley explained that each star keeps an orbit of its own.
Crowley's influence beyond Thelema came chiefly through four things. First, his definition of magick as the science and art of causing change in conformity with will, discussed on our page what is magick. Second, his scientific attitude. His periodical carried the motto the method of science, the aim of religion, and he demanded that every practice be recorded with its conditions and results, so that students judged by evidence rather than feeling; our page on the magical diary descends from that demand. Third, yoga, which he studied in earnest in Ceylon and India in the early 1900s and made one half of his system: yoga to still the mind, magick to direct it. Fourth, the knowledge and conversation of the holy guardian angel, which he made the central attainment of the path, as our page on the higher self describes.
A balanced judgment is not easy, because Crowley courted notoriety and got it. He was learned, inventive and often a clear, practical teacher; his tables of correspondence and his writing on yoga and ritual are used by many who reject his religion. He also treated many of those closest to him badly, and his claim to be the prophet of a new age is a matter of faith, not evidence. The fairest course is the one this site takes with every source: use what proves sound in practice, and judge the rest by its fruits.
The Qabalah writers
In the 1930s and 1940s three writers made the Qabalah of the orders available in plain books. Dion Fortune (1890 to 1946), the pen name of Violet Firth, had worked in early psychoanalytic therapy before she turned to occultism, and later led a magical group of her own. The Mystical Qabalah (1935) is still among the clearest introductions to the Tree of Life, treating each sphere as a level of consciousness as well as of the cosmos. She also wrote novels, among them The Winged Bull (1935), The Sea Priestess (1938) and Moon Magic, published after her death, in which magical ideas are taught through story. On fiction as a teacher, see our essay on magic in fiction.
Israel Regardie (1907 to 1985), who had been Crowley's secretary, published two books in 1932: A Garden of Pomegranates, an outline of the Qabalah, and The Tree of Life, a study of ceremonial magic as a spiritual discipline. In America Paul Foster Case (1884 to 1954) devoted his life to the tarot as a book of Qabalistic symbols and wrote The Tarot: A Key to the Wisdom of the Ages (1947). The attributions all three taught came from the London order and are those set out on our page on the tarot.
Jung and the psychological reading
Carl Gustav Jung (1875 to 1961), whose early study of a medium is described on our page on mesmerism and Spiritualism, spent much of his later career on alchemy. In Psychology and Alchemy (1944) and later works he argued that the alchemists had unknowingly projected the processes of their own unconscious onto the substances in their flasks. The stages of the work were for him images of individuation: the lifelong process by which a person integrates the unconscious and becomes whole.
His influence on practitioners has been immense. Archetype, shadow, projection and the method he called active imagination have entered nearly every modern book on magic, and many students now read gods, trumps and alchemical images first of all as figures of the psyche. Our page on shadow and integration uses his language where it helps.
Historians of chemistry have been less kind. Since the 1980s they have shown that most alchemists did real laboratory work, that their obscure language usually described practical operations, and that the purely spiritual reading of alchemy owes more to Victorian occultists than to the alchemists, though many alchemists did see their work as a devotion as well. Jung's reading remains a powerful way to use the images. It is not a reliable account of what most alchemists thought they were doing, and our page on alchemy keeps the two apart under furnace or soul.
Bardon and the solitary course
A different kind of book appeared in 1956. Franz Bardon (1909 to 1958), a Czech teacher of magic who survived imprisonment under the Nazis and died in Communist custody, published Initiation into Hermetics, a course in ten steps, each with exercises for mind, soul and body. Its foundation is elemental balance. The student begins by listing his or her own virtues and faults, sorting them by the four elements, and works to strengthen what is weak and master what is excessive before attempting anything further. The scheme is close in spirit to the elemental grades of the orders, but it needs no lodge and no ceremony, and for many it was the first workable course of self initiation. Its questions are those of our page on working alone, and its later exercises are demanding enough that the cautions there about forcing the pace apply.
In the same years a retired English civil servant, Gerald Gardner, was publishing books on what he presented as a surviving religion of witchcraft. Much of its ritual came from the Hermetic revival: the circle and its quarters, the pentagrams, the elemental tools. That story, and how the two paths differ, is told on our page on Hermetic magic and modern witchcraft.
From the counterculture to chaos magic
In the 1960s and 1970s esotericism became part of the counterculture. Young seekers of a new Age of Aquarius read astrology, Theosophy, Crowley and Jung side by side, and by the 1980s the loose movement that grew from this was widely known as the New Age. Optimistic, eclectic and therapeutic, it soon became a market as well. In the tarot boom that followed, the London pack of 1909 and the pack painted for Crowley, first published in 1969, were printed in enormous numbers, and new packs appeared by the hundred.
Chaos magic, which took shape in England in the late 1970s, moved the other way, away from doctrine altogether. Its founders treated belief as a tool to be taken up and put down, kept the techniques and discarded the cosmologies, and judged everything by results. Their acknowledged precursor was the artist Austin Osman Spare (1886 to 1956), who in The Book of Pleasure (1913) described turning a written desire into a sigil, charging it in a state of emptied mind and then forgetting it; our page on sigils and talismans gives the method. Chaos magic sharpened a real question, how much of a system is technique and how much belief, though in discarding doctrine it risks discarding the aim of self knowledge as well.
The scholars
The same decades brought the scholars. In 1945 Coptic books found near Nag Hammadi in Egypt included three Hermetic texts, one of them, the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth, lost since antiquity; they are described on our page on the Hermetic texts. Between 1945 and 1954 the classical scholars A. D. Nock and A. J. Festugiere completed a critical edition of the Corpus Hermeticum and the Asclepius, with a French translation, the foundation of every reliable modern version.
In 1964 the English historian Frances Yates published Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition. She showed how seriously the Renaissance had taken Hermes, and portrayed Bruno as a Hermetic magus rather than a martyr for modern science. She also argued that the Hermetic image of the magus who acts upon the world helped prepare the scientific revolution. That larger thesis is now largely rejected. Historians of science found that Hermetic ideas played little part in the work that mattered: Copernicus mentions Trismegistus once, in passing, and Kepler attacked the Hermetic number mysticism of the English physician Robert Fludd. Her book nonetheless made the tradition a respectable subject. In 1965 a Paris institution established the first university chair in the history of esotericism, and further chairs followed from 1999, in Amsterdam and then in England.
A century in print
| Year | Work | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 1904 | The Book of the Law | Founding text of Thelema |
| 1909 | 777 | Crowley's tables of correspondence |
| 1929 | Magick in Theory and Practice | Crowley's definition of magick |
| 1932 | A Garden of Pomegranates | Regardie's outline of the Qabalah |
| 1935 | The Mystical Qabalah | Fortune's guide to the Tree |
| 1937 to 1940 | The London order's papers | The curriculum made public |
| 1944 | Psychology and Alchemy | Alchemy read as individuation |
| 1945 to 1954 | Critical edition of the Corpus Hermeticum | Reliable texts at last |
| 1954 | Witchcraft Today | Modern witchcraft made public |
| 1956 | Initiation into Hermetics | A course of elemental balance |
| 1964 | Giordano Bruno and the Hermetic Tradition | The tradition enters scholarship |
The twentieth century did for Hermetic magic what printing did for the Hermetica in the fifteenth: it put everything into circulation. Rituals once given under oath, the full tables of correspondence, the grade lectures and reliable texts of the ancient sources all became available to anyone. Self initiation, a doubtful idea in 1900, became the normal way to begin.
The price was eclecticism. With every system on the same shelf, many students took a little from each and finished none, and the coherence a teacher or a lodge had once supplied was easily lost. The century's best writers, Crowley, Fortune and Bardon among them, saw the danger and answered it in the same way: choose one course, follow it in order, and keep an honest record.