Esotericism

The Perennial Philosophy

The belief that one wisdom lies beneath all religions has shaped the Hermetic tradition from Ficino to the present. It deserves to be understood, and it needs to be handled with care.

There is an old and attractive idea that beneath the differences of the world's religions lies a single truth, known to the wise of every age and clothed differently by each people. Under various names it has run through the Hermetic tradition since the Renaissance, and it still shapes how many practitioners read their sources: Hermes beside Thoth and Odin, the Tree of Life beside the chakras, the alchemical marriage beside yin and yang. Its usual name is the perennial philosophy. This page traces its history, sets out the case against it, and suggests how to compare traditions without dissolving them.

In brief

  • The perennial philosophy holds that one wisdom underlies all religions. It grew from the Renaissance belief in an ancient theology descending from Hermes.
  • Theosophy recast it as a hidden wisdom religion, and the Traditionalists of the twentieth century as a primordial tradition betrayed by the modern world.
  • Historians reply that traditions differ deeply, that the claim cannot be tested, and that it tends to flatten and appropriate.
  • The Hermetic tradition is itself a work of comparison. The remedy is to compare well: differences first, likeness second, identity never assumed.

From ancient theology to perennial philosophy

The idea entered the Hermetic tradition through the ancient theology of the Renaissance. Marsilio Ficino, introducing his translation of the Hermetica, set out a chain of sages through whom one true wisdom had passed, from Hermes Trismegistus through Orpheus and Pythagoras to Plato. The chain was a historical mistake, as our history explains, but the habit of mind it encouraged outlived it.

The phrase itself came a few generations later. In 1540 Agostino Steuco, a learned Augustinian canon and librarian to the pope, published On the Perennial Philosophy. He argued that one wisdom had been given to humanity at the beginning, that its traces survived among the Egyptians, Chaldeans and Greeks as well as the Hebrews, and that Christianity was its fulfillment. It was a defense of the Church, not a declaration that all religions are equal. In 1714 the philosopher Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz used the phrase in a letter, in a modest sense of his own. If one drew out the traces of truth scattered among the ancient philosophers, he wrote, one would extract gold from the mud, and the result would be a kind of perennial philosophy. He meant a harvest of sound ideas from many schools; later writers gave the phrase a far larger meaning.

Concordance

In 1992 a French historian proposed six characteristics by which the currents of Western esotericism can be recognized, discussed on our page on defining esotericism. Two of them he called secondary, because they are common but not universal. One is the practice of concordance: the tendency to look for agreement between traditions, to find a common root beneath different religions and philosophies, and to hope that recognizing it would bring them into harmony. Pico della Mirandola, who offered in 1486 to defend nine hundred theses drawn from every school he knew, is the classic Renaissance example. The perennial philosophy is concordance raised into a doctrine.

The wisdom religion

In the nineteenth century the idea took a new form. Helena Blavatsky and the society she cofounded in New York in 1875, whose rise is told on our page on mesmerism and Spiritualism, taught that all religions descend from a single ancient wisdom religion, preserved intact by a hidden brotherhood of adepts and only partly reflected in the public faiths. Its motto, borrowed from an Indian source, was that there is no religion higher than truth, and one of its declared aims was the comparative study of religion, philosophy and science.

This version differed from Steuco's in two ways that mattered. It no longer placed Christianity at the summit; if anything, the summit had moved to India and Tibet. And it claimed access to the original wisdom through living Masters rather than through texts. The first change opened Western readers to Asian traditions on a large scale. The second put the whole construction beyond the reach of historical evidence.

The Traditionalists

In the twentieth century the most rigorous perennialists were also the fiercest critics of Theosophy. Rene Guenon (1886 to 1951), a French writer who passed through the occultist circles of Paris before rejecting them, held that a primordial tradition of superhuman origin lies behind the orthodox religions, each of which preserves it in its own form. The modern West, he argued in The Crisis of the Modern World (1927) and The Reign of Quantity and the Signs of the Times (1945), had broken with tradition altogether and was sliding toward the end of a cosmic cycle, ruled by quantity, materialism and individualism. Spiritual realization required regular initiation: attachment to a living tradition through an unbroken chain of transmission. On that ground he dismissed Theosophy, Spiritualism and most modern occultism as counterfeits. He himself entered Islam through a Sufi order and spent his last two decades in Cairo.

Frithjof Schuon (1907 to 1998) refined the doctrine in The Transcendent Unity of Religions (1948). The religions, he argued, really do differ, and even contradict one another, in their outward or exoteric forms, and each must be kept whole. Their unity is transcendent: it is found only at the summit, in an esoteric knowledge beyond all form. Ananda Coomaraswamy (1877 to 1947), a scholar of Indian and medieval art who spent his last thirty years as a museum curator in Boston, brought the same outlook to traditional art, arguing that the craftsmen of every traditional society worked from a common metaphysics.

Traditionalism attracted serious and learned people, and its critique of modern shallowness still finds readers. It should also be said plainly that some later admirers turned its contempt for modernity toward authoritarian politics.

Huxley's anthology

The phrase reached a wide public through the English novelist Aldous Huxley, whose anthology The Perennial Philosophy appeared in 1945. Huxley gathered short passages from Christian, Hindu, Buddhist, Taoist and Sufi writers under headings such as charity, prayer, self knowledge and grace, with a commentary of his own. He described the perennial philosophy as a threefold teaching: a metaphysics that recognizes a divine reality underlying the world of things, lives and minds; a psychology that finds in the soul something like that reality, or even identical with it; and an ethic that makes knowledge of this divine ground the final end of human life. Such knowledge, he added, comes only to those who make themselves loving, pure in heart and poor in spirit.

Huxley's version is gentler than Guenon's and more practical. It is also, unmistakably, the mysticism of a particular kind of educated English reader of the 1940s, and it chooses its passages to fit. That is the problem in miniature.

The case against

Most historians of religion and of esotericism do not accept the perennial philosophy, for three main reasons.

Traditions differ deeply
Studied in their own languages and settings, the differences between traditions go all the way down. Buddhist emptiness, the Brahman of the Upanishads, the God of the Hebrew prophets and the One of Plotinus answer different questions in different ways. A philosopher of religion argued in 1978 that there is no unshaped experience: mystics experience in the terms their tradition has prepared, so that the agreement perennialists find is often produced by translating everything into one vocabulary.
The claim cannot be tested
A hidden unity beyond all forms, known only to initiates, is not something historical evidence can confirm or refute. A historian can show that one text borrowed from another. No historian can show that two traditions express one transcendent truth. The claim may be true, but it is a religious claim and should be held as one.
It flattens and appropriates
To say that every tradition really means what one's own system means is to stop listening to it. The habit has made Western esotericists careless readers of Jewish Kabbalah, of yoga and of indigenous religions, lifting their symbols out of the communities that keep them and filing them under Western headings. Living traditions have a right to be understood on their own terms.

Some recent popular writers apply the same claim within the West, describing every esoteric current from the Gnostics to the occult revival as one consistent structure. The same objections apply. The currents are related, but they disagree about the most basic questions, including whether the world is a god or a prison. None of this means the perennialists were foolish to look. Their search encouraged tolerance, curiosity and the serious study of other faiths at a time when these were rare.

The Hermetic case

Students of Hermeticism have a particular reason to think about this, because their tradition is itself a product of comparison. The figure of Hermes Trismegistus was born when Greeks in Egypt decided that Thoth and their own Hermes were one god. The Hermetica combine Platonic and Stoic philosophy with Egyptian religion, and the first treatise of the Corpus Hermeticum echoes the book of Genesis. In the Renaissance, Christian Kabbalah read Jewish Kabbalah through Christian and Platonic eyes, and the Hermetic Qabalah of the revival grew from it.

The revival carried the method furthest. Its tables of correspondence join a planet, a metal, a color and a sphere of the Tree of Life, and the larger tables add columns of gods. Under the planet Jupiter, which they assign to the sphere Chesed, they gather the Roman god of that name, his Greek counterpart Zeus, and gods of Egypt and India judged to share his office of generous rule. Used as a map of analogies, such a table is a fine tool for meditation and ritual design. Read as a statement that these gods are one being under several names, it claims something no table can know, and something their worshippers, ancient and modern, would often deny.

How to compare well

The answer is not to give up comparison, which is how understanding begins, but to compare with discipline. The Hermetic maxim supplies the rule. As our essay on as above, so below points out, the Emerald Tablet says that what is below is like what is above, not that it is the same. Analogy is not identity. Several habits follow.

  • Meet each thing in its own setting first: its language, its date, the people who used it and what they used it for.
  • List the differences before the likenesses. Likeness is easy to see and flattering to find; difference takes work.
  • Compare function as well as appearance. Two symbols that look alike may do opposite things in their own systems.
  • Keep three claims apart: that two things resemble each other, that one influenced the other, and that both express one truth. The first needs observation, the second historical evidence, the third faith.
  • Keep the native names. Calling everything by your own system's terms is translation passing itself off as discovery.

Our journal essay on East and West applies the same discipline to borrowed practices.

Practice

Differences first

  1. Choose two symbols from different traditions that are often said to mean the same thing: for example the alchemical marriage of Sun and Moon and the Chinese pairing of yin and yang.
  2. Read a short account of each, from a source written within its tradition or by a careful historian of it. Note the date, the language and the use of each.
  3. On a page of your diary, write at least five differences between them before anything else: in origin, in purpose, in who used them, and in what they were never meant to say.
  4. Only then list the likenesses. Mark each as a resemblance, a possible influence or an assumed identity, and strike out any identity you cannot support.
  5. Finish with one sentence that states the relation using the word like and never the word is. Return to the page after a month and see whether the sentence still holds.