Journal

The Magician in the Story

Stories have taught the Western tradition as much as its treatises have. They are poor guides to what magic does and good guides to what it feels like, and they are worth reading for that.

When people ask how to begin, I give the answer this site gives: a notebook, a chair and twenty minutes a day. When they ask what to read first, I have more than once surprised them by suggesting a novel. The tradition has been shaped by stories at least as much as by arguments, and some of its most durable ideas came in through the door of a romance.

Even the Hermetica begin with a story. The first treatise is not an argument but the account of a vision, told in the first person by a seeker who falls into a deep stillness and is addressed by Mind.

Stories at the source

The only Latin novel of antiquity to survive complete ends in an initiation. In the Golden Ass of Apuleius, written in the second century, a young man named Lucius meddles with a witch's ointment, hoping to become a bird, and becomes a donkey instead. After many misadventures the goddess Isis restores him in the midst of her procession and receives him into her mysteries. His account of that initiation is deliberately reticent: he came to the boundary of death, he says, saw the sun shining at midnight, and may tell no more. The moral is plain: curiosity without preparation makes a man a beast, and devotion makes him human again. It is a pleasing accident that the Latin Asclepius was long copied among the works of Apuleius, though he did not write it.

The Rosicrucian affair produced its own romance. The Chemical Wedding of Christian Rosenkreutz of 1616 is a story in seven days, in which an old man attends a royal wedding that turns out to be an alchemical operation, complete with beheadings, a tower and a resurrection. Its probable author later called it a jest. Of the books of the affair, described on our page on the Rosicrucian manifestos, it is the one readers still finish for pleasure.

Novels and poems

In 1842 a Victorian novelist published Zanoni, a romance of two immortal adepts in the age of the French Revolution. One of them takes a young Englishman as his pupil. The pupil, impatient, breaks the conditions of his training in his master's absence and is confronted by a horror the book calls the Dweller of the Threshold. Occultists seized on the figure. It passed into Theosophical writing and beyond as the name for whatever the unprepared student meets at the edge of the work, and many still speak of it without knowing they are quoting a novel.

Goethe's Faust opens with a scholar who has mastered every faculty and found them all empty, and who turns to magic. He contemplates the sign of the macrocosm, summons the Spirit of the Earth, and is dismissed by it as too small to grasp what he has called. The long drama that follows turns on a bargain for experience and power without the slow change that should have earned them.

Dion Fortune, whose textbook on the Qabalah appeared in 1935, also wrote novels, and said in effect that the textbook gave the theory and the novels the practice. The Sea Priestess and Moon Magic, the second published after her death, have long been recommended to newcomers as the best way to feel what the work is like from inside: the long preparation, the slow building of atmosphere, and the pressure of ritual and ordinary life on each other. And Yeats, who belonged for many years to the London order founded in 1888, put more of what he learned there into his poems than into his prose: the widening gyre, the tower, the golden bird that sings in Byzantium.

A grammar in a game

Nor have the stories stopped with novels. A tabletop role playing game first published in 1987 imagines a medieval order of wizards named for Hermes, with one of the more intelligent systems of imaginary magic ever devised. Every effect is built from two kinds of art. Five are verbs: to create, to perceive, to transform, to destroy and to control. Ten are nouns: animals, water, air, the body, plants, fire, images, mind, earth and magical power itself. A spell is a sentence. To make a flame is creo ignem, I create fire. To read a thought is to perceive mind.

Its players argue among themselves about whether Hermetic, in the game, means of Hermes or sealed. The answer is both, since the hermetic seal was itself named for Hermes, as Tobias Varnell explains in his essay on what makes magic Hermetic. What interests me is the grammar. The designers saw something true: that in the Western tradition magic is a language before it is a power. The tables of correspondences are a vocabulary. Venus, copper, green, the rose and Friday are words of one family, and a talisman is a sentence composed in them.

What the stories get right and wrong

The best stories get three things right. They treat magic as a language. They know that the apprenticeship is long: the pupil in Zanoni fails because he will not wait, and Fortune's characters spend chapters preparing for a single night. And they know that the work costs something, and that the cost is paid in the person. Faust stakes his soul, Zanoni gives up his immortality, and Shakespeare's Prospero ends The Tempest by abjuring his art, vowing to break his staff and drown his book.

Most stories, especially on screens, get four things wrong. They make magic power over things: flame from the fingertips, doors that open at a word. They make it spectacular, when real practice is almost invisible to an onlooker. They make it fast, because a plot cannot wait a year for a result. And they make it easy, at least for the hero, who has a gift. None of this is a fault in a story. A novel in which the heroine sits in a chair every morning for eleven years, keeps a diary and slowly becomes kinder would be true and very hard to sell. But a reader who takes the story for a manual will be disappointed, and may conclude, since no fire comes from the fingers, that nothing is happening.

Fiction in pictures

I came to this tradition through a kind of fiction with no plot. Training as a bookbinder, I was given an old facsimile of an alchemical emblem book to rebind, and spent a week with its plates before reading a word of its text. Emblem books such as Michael Maier's Atalanta Fugiens of 1617 teach by picture: a wind carrying a child in its belly, the earth suckling an infant, a king swimming in the sea and crying out for rescue, each with a short verse and a longer discourse. They are not true in the way a recipe is true. They are true as a story is, giving the mind something to live inside until it changes shape. The alchemists drew them because images do work that arguments cannot, and our page on alchemy describes the stages they pictured.

Reading them as stories

So read the stories, and read them as what they are. Let the Golden Ass show you what curiosity without preparation does, and Zanoni what impatience meets at the threshold. Do not read them for results. They cannot tell you what magic will do, and they were never meant to. What they do better than any treatise is train the faculty on which the whole work depends, the imagination: the power to enter a world made of images and come back changed. A novel read slowly is an exercise in exactly that, and a pleasant one, which in a discipline as long as ours is no small thing.