Self Transformation

Initiation

Initiation can name a ceremony, an inner change or a transmission from teacher to pupil. The three are easily confused, and only one of them can be judged by its fruits.

Few words in the esoteric vocabulary are used so freely, or claimed so jealously, as initiation. It can mean a ceremony performed on a particular evening, a change in a person that no ceremony could produce, or a line of authority passed from teacher to pupil. The three are often confused, sometimes on purpose.

In brief

  • The word means a beginning, and it first named admission to the ancient mysteries.
  • Initiation can be a ceremony, an inner process or a transmission, and the three do not always coincide.
  • Rites of passage everywhere follow a pattern of separation, threshold and return.
  • Genuine initiation shows itself in changed conduct. It cannot be bought.

The word and the mysteries

Initiation comes from the Latin initium, a beginning. The Romans used the plural, initia, for the mystery rites of the Greek world, and Cicero, writing of the mysteries of Eleusis, played on the word: the rites are rightly called beginnings, he said, since through them we learned the first principles of life, and received a way to live with joy and to die with better hope. The Greek initiate was a mystes, from a verb meaning to close the eyes or the lips. A fragment ascribed to Plutarch compares the soul at death with those being initiated into the great mysteries. From the beginning, initiation was a rehearsal of dying in order to live differently.

Eleusis

The most famous mysteries were celebrated each autumn at Eleusis, near Athens, in honor of Demeter and her daughter Persephone, whose descent to the underworld and return the myth told. They were performed for about a thousand years, until the end of the fourth century, and were open to men and women, slave and free, to anyone who spoke Greek and was clean of bloodshed.

The candidates purified themselves in the sea and walked in procession along the Sacred Way from Athens. What happened at night in the great hall of initiation is not known. Ancient writers speak of things done, things said and things shown, and of a further degree whose members were called the epoptai, those who have seen. The secret was kept for centuries, and profaning it was a capital crime at Athens. What the initiates carried away was not a doctrine but a changed relation to death. The Homeric Hymn to Demeter calls blessed the mortal who has seen these rites, and says that the uninitiated has no such portion when he lies in the darkness below.

Lucius and the threshold

The fullest first person account of an ancient initiation that survives is found in a novel. In the eleventh and last book of the Metamorphoses of Apuleius, better known as The Golden Ass, the hero Lucius, turned into a donkey by a magical experiment gone wrong, is restored by the goddess Isis and asks to enter her mysteries. The priest makes him wait until the goddess herself names the day, warning that to rush unbidden is as wrong as to delay when called. The rite, he explains, is performed as a voluntary death and a salvation granted by favor. After ten days without meat or wine, Lucius is led at night into the inner temple, and tells what he is permitted to tell.

I approached the boundary of death and trod the threshold of Proserpina, and having been carried through all the elements I returned. At midnight I saw the sun shining with a brilliant light. I came face to face with the gods below and the gods above, and worshipped them close at hand.

Apuleius, The Golden Ass, book XI

The Hermetic writings preserve initiation of another kind. Treatise XIII and the Coptic Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth are dialogues in which a teacher leads a pupil through rebirth into vision, as our page on Hermetic rebirth describes. There is no temple. The ceremony is a conversation, a prayer and a silence, and the ordeal is the pupil's own confusion.

Three meanings of initiation

A ceremony of admission
The fraternal lodges of the eighteenth century and the magical orders of the nineteenth admitted members through dramatic rituals, the candidate often blindfolded, led through darkness and challenged at a door. In the orders each stage of training was marked in this way, as our page on the grades of the revival shows. A ceremony is a public fact, with a date.
An inner process
The change the ceremony points to: a real reordering of understanding and conduct. It may happen without any ceremony, and it may fail to happen with one.
A transmission
Something handed from teacher to pupil: knowledge, a method, an authority or, some believe, an influence that cannot be put into words. Transmission from master to disciple is among the characteristics by which scholars have tried to define esotericism.

Much confusion comes from running the three together, as when a group implies that its ceremonies produce the inner process, or a teacher offers a lineage as proof of attainment. The most uncompromising claim came from the Traditionalists. Rene Guenon, in essays on initiation collected in 1946, argued that true initiation requires an unbroken chain of regular transmission within a traditional organization, so that no effort of one's own can replace it and self initiation is a contradiction in terms. Our page on the perennial philosophy discusses the school.

We are skeptical, chiefly on historical grounds. The lineages claimed by the Western magical orders do not survive examination. The London order of 1888 rested its authority on a cipher manuscript and a German adept who has never been shown to exist, and its real achievement was a new synthesis. A good teacher saves years, and a community gives correction and witness that no book can. These are real goods, not a monopoly. Our page on self initiation puts the balance plainly: a ceremony can begin what only the student can complete.

Separation, threshold and return

In 1909 the French ethnographer Arnold van Gennep published The Rites of Passage, a comparative study of the ceremonies that mark birth, coming of age, marriage, death and entry into a group. He found the same three phases again and again. The person is first separated from the old state, then passes a period at the margin, belonging to neither state, and is finally incorporated into the community in the new one, often with a shared meal. He called the middle phase liminal, from the Latin limen, threshold: the very word Apuleius uses for the threshold of Proserpina.

The anthropologist Victor Turner, writing in the 1960s, made the threshold his special subject. People in the liminal state, he observed, are betwixt and between: stripped of status, bound to one another by a plain fellowship he called communitas, and open to instruction as at no other time. The threshold is dangerous and fertile at once.

The three phases of a rite of passage
Phase In a ceremony In a life
Separation The candidate is set apart, washed or blindfolded An old role ends: a job lost, a home left, a certainty broken
Threshold Darkness, ordeal, instruction, the passage through the door The uncertain middle, when the old has gone and the new has not come
Return The candidate is received, given a new name, and shares a meal The change is taken into daily life and recognized by others

The same shape appears in the Hermetic way, from instruction through turning to rebirth, and in the alchemical rhythm of dissolving and coagulating. Most people have lived it several times without any ceremony at all.

The dweller of the threshold

In esoteric literature the threshold is guarded. In Zanoni, an occult novel of 1842 by an English novelist, an impatient pupil breaks into his master's forbidden knowledge before he is ready and meets the Dweller of the Threshold, a horror that haunts him from then on. Later teachers spoke of a guardian of the threshold and gave it an inward meaning: the guardian is formed from the aspirant's own unresolved faults and fears, and must be faced before going further.

Our page on shadow and integration describes this figure as the one who meets the aspirant at the door and turns out to wear the aspirant's own face. Every serious beginning provokes resistance, and the resistance takes the shape of whatever has not yet been faced: the fear of failure, an old shame, the conviction that one is not the kind of person who does this. The guardian is not defeated by force. Once recognized, it lets one pass. Meet it as the alchemists met the black stage, as a sign that the work has begun, gently and without drama.

Signs of genuine initiation

How can anyone tell whether an initiation has been real? Not by the splendor of the ceremony, the antiquity of the lineage or the vividness of the experience. The tradition's own answer is conduct. A person who has truly begun something new behaves differently afterward: more responsibly, more truthfully, with less need to be thought advanced. The signs of progress on our page on the Great Work apply here unchanged.

Most real initiations do not happen in temples. They happen in illness, bereavement and failure, in the care of a child or a dying parent, in the long discipline of a craft. These ordeals are not chosen, and they follow the three phases exactly: something is taken away, there is a time of not knowing, and a person comes back changed or embittered. Which of the two often depends on whether the passage is met consciously, with the willingness to stay at the threshold without fleeing.

The grades of the orders are best read in the same spirit, not as ranks won once and held for life but as a map of stages that a life passes through many times, at deeper levels. A person may be an adept in one part of life and a beginner in another.

Initiation for sale

Because initiation is valued, it is sold, and has been for a long time: Apuleius has Lucius go on to two further initiations, each with its fees, and at one point sell his clothes to pay. Some groups offer grades for fees that rise with each step, and promise powers that no ceremony can confer. Secrecy, which in the ancient mysteries protected an experience from being cheapened, can also protect a group from scrutiny and hide abuse. The old discipline of silence, the fourth of the four powers, is about not talking away one's own experience. It is not a duty to conceal what others do to you.

Caution

No ceremony can do the work for you, and no genuine teacher needs your money, your secrecy or your obedience. Any one of the warning signs listed on our page on ethics and safety is reason enough to walk away.

Practice

A rite of beginning

  1. Choose the beginning you wish to mark: a course of study, a period of practice, a change of life. Write in your diary, in one sentence, what you are beginning and for how long.
  2. Separation. On the chosen day set aside an hour. Wash, put on clean and plain clothes, and put every screen away. On a slip of paper write one habit or attitude you mean to leave behind.
  3. Threshold. Stand outside the door of the room where you practice. Name honestly what is most likely to stop you finishing what you begin, then step across deliberately. Sit for ten minutes in silence with your sentence before you, and read it aloud once.
  4. Return. Stand, cross the threshold again, and tear up the slip. Then eat a simple meal, with someone you trust if you can, whether or not you explain why.
  5. That evening, describe the rite in your diary and how each phase felt. Note the date on which the period ends, and read the entry again then.