Esotericism

Hermetic Magic and Modern Witchcraft

Modern witchcraft is often presented as the opposite of ceremonial magic, yet much of its ritual came from the same source. What was borrowed, what is different, and why both deserve respect.

Modern witchcraft and Hermetic ceremonial magic are often presented as opposites: the one green, intuitive and close to the earth, the other learned, hierarchical and bookish. Anyone who has watched both at work will notice how much they share. A circle cast and the four quarters called, a pentagram drawn in the air, a knife and a cup on the altar: these came into witchcraft, by routes that can be traced, from the Hermetic revival. This page sets out that history, what was borrowed, and what is genuinely different.

In brief

  • The witch trials of early modern Europe and the modern religion of witchcraft are separate histories. The theory that joined them is rejected by historians.
  • Modern witchcraft was made public by Gerald Gardner from 1949, and much of its ritual was rewritten by Doreen Valiente in the 1950s.
  • Its circle, quarters, pentagrams, tools, degrees and ritual structure were drawn from the Hermetic revival and the grimoires it published.
  • It differs as a religion of nature, with goddess and god, seasonal festivals and the coven. Yet each path does some of what the other does.

Two histories

The witch trials of early modern Europe, which reached their height between about 1560 and 1630 and cost perhaps forty to sixty thousand lives, belong to a different story. The accused were overwhelmingly ordinary people caught up in local quarrels, fears and the panics of the courts. Some were village healers and charmers; very few practiced anything like ritual magic; and there is no good evidence that any belonged to an organized pagan religion.

The theory that they did was popularized by the Egyptologist Margaret Murray (1863 to 1963), whose book of 1921 argued that the trial records described a surviving fertility religion older than Christianity, organized in covens of thirteen and devoted to a horned god. Her work was widely read, and she was asked to write the article on witchcraft for a standard encyclopedia. Historians have since rejected it. She quoted the trial records selectively, left out the impossible elements that sat beside the details she used, and read confessions extracted under pressure as plain testimony. Her theory nonetheless supplied the founding story of modern witchcraft.

Gerald Gardner

Gerald Gardner (1884 to 1964) spent most of his working life in Asia as a planter and customs officer, and retired to the south of England in the late 1930s with a strong interest in folklore and magic. He joined an occult theatrical group near the New Forest, and according to his own account he was initiated there in 1939 into a coven of witches who had kept the old religion in secret. Whether such a coven existed, and if so what it practiced, has been argued ever since; no independent evidence of its antiquity has been found.

Bound, he said, by his coven's secrecy and by the law, he first presented the material in a novel, High Magic's Aid (1949), set among medieval witches and a ceremonial magician. After the repeal in 1951 of the old English law against witchcraft he published Witchcraft Today (1954), with an introduction by Margaret Murray, and The Meaning of Witchcraft (1959). In the same years he ran a small museum of witchcraft lore on the Isle of Man. He had also met the aging Aleister Crowley in 1947 and been admitted to a Thelemic order. Gardner's witchcraft, which its followers came to call Wicca, spread from his own covens through Britain and, from the 1960s, to America and beyond.

The Book of Shadows

Gardner's covens worked from a handwritten book of rituals and instructions called the Book of Shadows, which he presented as the inheritance of the old coven, copied by each new witch from the book of an initiator. It is a discovery story of a familiar type. The London order of 1888 claimed authority from a manuscript in cipher of uncertain origin, and the grimoires had for centuries been attributed to Solomon, Moses or a pope. In each case an ancient source is claimed for a book that proves, on examination, to be recent work built from older materials.

Scholars who have studied the surviving manuscripts can identify many of those materials. The early Book of Shadows contains passages from Crowley, ritual from the Key of Solomon in the edition of Mathers, verses adapted from older poets, elements of the ceremonies of the fraternal lodges, and material from an American folklorist's book of 1899 on witches in Italy. What remains, and might have come from an older coven, is a small residue of unknown origin.

Much of the Book of Shadows used today was rewritten by Doreen Valiente (1922 to 1999), who was initiated by Gardner in 1953 and became his high priestess. She recognized the passages from Crowley, thought them out of keeping with an old religion of nature and likely to harm its reputation, and cut many of them, writing new material of her own in their place. Her best known work is a version of the charge of the Goddess, the address in which the Goddess speaks to her worshippers, and it remains one of the most widely used texts of the religion. Valiente later broke with Gardner over publicity and authority, and in her own books she wrote frankly about where the rituals had come from.

What was borrowed

Set beside the rituals of the Hermetic revival, the borrowings are plain.

The circle and the quarters
The circle is cast with a blade, and the four quarters are called in turn, east, south, west and north. Their guardians are often called the watchtowers, a term that came into the revival from the angelic system of John Dee, whose great table of the angels is divided into four watchtowers; see our page on John Dee.
The pentagrams
The invoking and banishing pentagrams drawn at the quarters come from the pentagram rituals of the London order, which Crowley had published; see the pentagram ritual.
The tools
The athame or black handled knife, the wand, the cup and the pentacle answer to the four elemental weapons of the revival, and some of them, with their consecrations, come from the Key of Solomon that Mathers published in 1889.
The degrees
Gardner's covens had three degrees of initiation, on the model of the three degrees of the fraternal lodges, with ceremonies of challenge, oath and presentation of the tools that resemble lodge ritual.
The shape of the rite
Purification, opening, invocation, the working, the blessing and sharing of food and drink, and a formal closing follow the pattern of ceremonial magic set out on our page on the structure of ritual.

What differs

The differences are as real as the borrowings. Modern witchcraft is first of all a religion of nature. It honors a Goddess, often linked with the moon and the earth, and a horned God of the wild and of death and rebirth, and it finds the sacred in the turning of the seasons. Its calendar is the wheel of the year: eight festivals at the solstices, the equinoxes and the four cross quarter days between them, a cycle that took shape in Gardner's circles from the late 1950s. Its working unit is the coven, a small group led by a high priestess and a high priest. And it has always included practical folk magic: healing, protection, charms, herbs and the raising of power for a stated end.

Hermetic ceremonial magic, as the revival shaped it, has a different center. Its deity is usually conceived as one, in a Hebrew, Christian or philosophical frame, approached through divine names and the spheres of the Tree of Life. Its calendar is the planetary week and the astrological year. Its training is graded study, alone or in a lodge, and its aim is the purification of the student and conscious union with the higher self. In practice each path does some of each. There are ceremonial magicians who keep the seasonal festivals, and witches whose work is chiefly inward and contemplative.

Hermetic ceremonial practice and modern witchcraft compared
Feature Hermetic ceremonial practice Modern witchcraft
Circle The boundary of the operator's sphere, usually set by a banishing A sacred space between the worlds, cast with a blade, often for a group
Quarters Four elements, with archangels and divine names Four elements, with the guardians of the watchtowers
Tools Wand, cup, dagger and pentacle, made in stages of training Athame, wand, cup and pentacle, with cauldron, broom and others
Deity One divine source, approached through names and the sephiroth A Goddess and a God, known by many names
Calendar Planetary days and hours, astrological timing Eight seasonal festivals and the phases of the moon
Structure Graded study on the Tree of Life, alone or in a lodge The coven and its three degrees, or solitary practice
Aim Self knowledge and union with the higher self Worship, attunement to nature and practical magic

Later developments

From the 1960s witchcraft divided into many branches and spread across the English speaking world, absorbing feminist goddess spirituality, folklore and ecology on the way. The change that matters most for readers of this site was the rise of the solitary witch. From the 1970s, and above all the 1980s, books for those working without a coven taught people to dedicate or initiate themselves, and Valiente herself published a rite of self dedication in 1978. With the solitary witch came the personal Book of Shadows, no longer copied from an initiator but compiled by each practitioner from many sources: in effect a modern grimoire, and a close cousin of the magical diary this site recommends.

Witchcraft writers have also borrowed in the other direction. The seven principles of the Kybalion now appear in many popular books on witchcraft, sometimes as the ancient philosophy of the craft. Some popular books present them as the ancient heritage of the craft, misdate the Kybalion and name its authors with more confidence than the evidence allows. The principles can serve any practice, but they come from an American book of 1908 and should be taught as such.

An assessment

Historians now agree that modern witchcraft is a twentieth century creation assembled from older materials: ceremonial magic and the grimoires, the Romantic image of the witch as rebel and healer, the folklore of the countryside, Murray's theory, the fraternal lodges and the literature of the revival. A historian of British paganism set out the case at length in 1999, and many witches today accept it without difficulty.

That conclusion does not make the religion less serious, any more than the late date of the Hermetica or the modern origin of the Kybalion makes them worthless. A tradition is not validated by its age, and it is not refuted by its youth. Modern witchcraft has given many people a living relationship with nature, the seasons and the sacred, and its practice has been tested by more than seventy years of use. Its practitioners deserve the respect owed to those of any faith, and the student of Hermetic magic should recognize in their circle a relative, not a rival.