Esotericism

Defining Esotericism

The word is ancient, the category is modern, and scholars still disagree about where its borders lie. Four ways of drawing the map, and what each shows about the place of Hermeticism.

Esotericism is a word many people use and few can define. Practitioners use it for the inner meaning of every religion, booksellers for a shelf between astrology and self help, and historians for a family of currents in Western culture that runs from the Hermetica through alchemy and Christian Kabbalah to the occult revival. The word is older than the category, and the category is younger than almost everything it contains. This page traces both and sets out four ways in which scholars have drawn the map.

In brief

  • The Greek adjective meant belonging to an inner circle. The noun esotericism was coined in French in 1828.
  • The category was first drawn by a hostile Lutheran theologian in 1690 and was long kept out of the universities.
  • Scholars have defined esotericism as a secret universal tradition, an enchanted world view, a claim to higher knowledge, and rejected knowledge. Each catches something real.
  • Hermeticism is the oldest named member of the family, not the trunk of a single secret lineage.

The word and its history

The Greek adjective esoterikos means belonging to the inside, to an inner circle. Its earliest known appearance is in the second century of the common era, in a satire by Lucian of Samosata in which the philosophical schools are auctioned like slaves. A buyer is told that the follower of Aristotle on sale is double, one man outside and another within, and that he should call the one exoteric and the other esoteric. The joke depended on a distinction his readers already knew.

That distinction was old, and at first it had little to do with secrets. Aristotle refers to his exoteric discourses, apparently works for a general audience as opposed to the teaching given within his school, though he never used the word esoteric. He also mentions unwritten doctrines of Plato on first principles, and the Seventh Letter attributed to Plato says that the highest matters cannot be written down at all, but arise in the soul like a flame kindled by a leaping spark, after long companionship with the subject. From such passages later ages took the idea of a teaching reserved for the inner circle of a school, and later still of a hidden doctrine behind the public one.

The noun came much later. Esotericism, in its French form, first appears in 1828, in a critical history of Gnosticism by the Protestant historian Jacques Matter. Eliphas Levi made it current in the 1850s and popularized a second word, occultism, first recorded in French in 1842, and for about a century the two were used almost as synonyms. Historians now tend to keep occultism for the nineteenth and twentieth century movements that tried to reconcile the old material with science, and esotericism for the wider field.

A modern category

For most of their history the things now called esoteric were not thought of as one thing. An alchemist, a Christian kabbalist and a reader of the Hermetica might know one another's books, but none supposed that he belonged to a movement. The first writer to treat them as a single field was an enemy. In 1690 and 1691 the German Lutheran theologian Ehregott Daniel Colberg published a polemic called Platonic Hermetic Christianity, which gathered the followers of Paracelsus, the disciples of the mystic Valentin Weigel and the Christian theosophers into one heretical family, with its roots in the Platonists and Hermes. He meant to condemn them. In doing so he drew the outline of the field.

The Enlightenment kept the outline and changed the label, filing the same material under superstition, magic and the occult. The modern university, taking shape at the same time, defined itself partly by refusing to take any of it seriously, and its history was left to enthusiasts who wrote with more devotion than accuracy. Serious academic study began only in the twentieth century, with historians of the Renaissance such as Frances Yates, and the first university chair in the subject was established in Paris in 1965.

Four ways of drawing the map

Scholars broadly agree about what belongs in the field, from the Hermetica and Gnosticism to Theosophy and the occult revival. They disagree about what makes these things belong together. Four answers have been influential.

A secret inner tradition

The oldest answer is the esotericists' own. There is a single hidden wisdom at the heart of all religions, of which churches, mosques and temples teach only the outer shell, handed down in secret from age to age. Many writers of the occult revival held some version of it, as did the Traditionalists who followed Rene Guenon, and for a time so did scholars of religion who shared the conviction.

As history it has three problems. It assumes what it ought to prove, since one hidden tradition is a religious belief that historical evidence cannot establish. It masks real differences between currents that contradicted one another. And many of the currents it claims were never secret: Ficino printed his Hermes, Agrippa his magic, and the works of Boehme were sold openly in Amsterdam and London. The idea's own history is told on our page on the perennial philosophy.

An enchanted world view

In 1992 a French historian who held the Paris chair proposed a definition that dominated the field for a generation. Esotericism, he argued, is a form of thought recognizable by four essential characteristics, often joined by two secondary ones, which together describe a living and meaningful world rather than a machine.

The six characteristics, with Hermetic examples
Characteristic What it means A Hermetic example
Correspondences Real and symbolic links between all levels of the universe Above and below in the Emerald Tablet
Living nature Nature as a living, layered whole, full of soul The cosmos as a second god in treatise VIII
Imagination and mediations Images, rites, symbols and intermediate beings as ways to higher levels The animated statues of the Asclepius
Experience of transmutation Knowledge that transforms the knower The rebirth of Tat in treatise XIII
Concordance (secondary) A common root beneath different traditions The ancient theology, which set Hermes beside Moses and Plato
Transmission (secondary) Teaching handed from master to disciple The teacher and pupil of the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth

The scheme allowed currents to be compared point by point. Its weakness is its origin. Its author's own research lay in early modern Christian esotericism, above all Christian theosophy and the German philosophy of nature, and the six marks fit early modern Christian esotericism far better than other periods. Critics said it reasons from a favorite example and measures everything else by likeness to it. Ancient Gnosticism, which saw the cosmos as a prison, fits the second mark badly, yet most historians count it within the field or among its chief sources.

A claim to higher knowledge

Early in this century a German historian of religion proposed a looser framework. What unites esoteric discourse, he suggested, is a claim to higher knowledge, a key to the cosmos and to history superior to what churches or sciences offer, reached either through mediation, by revelation from gods, angels or spirits, or through personal experience. Secrecy, on this view, is less a fact about who holds the knowledge than a way of speaking about it. The Hermetic treatises, which set out their teaching at length and then command silence, are a fine example.

Rejected knowledge

The most influential recent proposal comes from a Dutch historian, who defined esotericism by what was done to it. From the Reformation onward, and again in the Enlightenment, both the churches and the new academy defined themselves against a body of ideas they rejected: paganized Christianity, magic, astrology, alchemy, the occult. That body, the dustbin of rejected knowledge in his phrase, is what we now call esotericism. The approach explains why such different things were filed together. Its critics reply that a category defined by rejection could include almost anything orthodoxy and science ever turned away, and that it casts esotericism as a victim, which is a romance of its own. Our essay on rejected knowledge takes up that romance.

Inside and outside

The field also describes itself, and the two descriptions rarely agree. Scholars call the difference emic and etic. An emic account gives the view from inside, in the participants' own terms: the alchemist's explanation of the Great Work, the initiate's account of a ceremony. An etic account gives the view from outside: when a text was written, who read it, what it borrowed. Sound history needs both.

Historians of esotericism also practice methodological agnosticism. They neither affirm nor deny that the higher worlds of their sources exist, or that a practice did what its practitioners claimed, because the tools of history cannot settle such questions. They can establish what was believed, when and by whom.

This site works in both registers and tries never to confuse them. When we date the Hermetic treatises to Roman Egypt, we speak as historians. When we say that the soul surrenders a power at each planetary sphere, we report the tradition in its own terms. When we recommend a practice, we speak as practitioners who have tested it. Our editorial standards describe how we mark these kinds of statement. A reader who keeps them apart can love the tradition without being deceived by its legends.

Is it Western?

The adjective Western has come under question. The Hermetica were written in Egypt. Much of the technical Hermetic literature was preserved and extended in Arabic, by Muslim, Christian, Jewish and pagan scholars, as our page on Hermes in the Middle Ages describes. The Kabbalah was Jewish, and Theosophy drew openly on Hindu and Buddhist ideas such as karma and reincarnation. Some scholars have therefore proposed speaking simply of esotericism.

Others keep the word for a good reason. The category was made in Europe, by churchmen and philosophers arguing about their own inheritance, and Western is a reminder that it is historical, not universal. Attempts to build an Eastern equivalent usually repeat the old assumption of a single hidden wisdom. For the student the lesson is the same either way: the tradition borrowed widely and should acknowledge what it borrowed, as our essay on East and West argues.

Where Hermeticism fits

Hermeticism is the oldest current in the field that bears a name of its own, and its name was lent to much that came after: alchemy was the Hermetic art, and the magicians of the nineteenth century called their whole synthesis Hermetic. It supplied several lasting ideas: a living cosmos, the likeness of above and below, a knowledge that saves, a way of return through the spheres. Each of the four definitions catches part of it.

But it is one member of a family, not the trunk from which the others grew. The relation between Hermeticism, Gnosticism, Neoplatonism, alchemy, Kabbalah and the rest is best described by the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein's idea of family resemblance: no single feature is shared by every member, yet each shares many features with some others, as relatives share a nose or a way of walking. That is a more modest picture than the secret lineage of the old histories. It is also truer. The section overview introduces the family, and our history of Hermeticism tells how the dream of one ancient wisdom arose and why it remained fruitful though mistaken.

Practice

Testing a text against the six marks

  1. Choose a short text or practice you know well: a Hermetic treatise, a chapter of the Kybalion, or a ritual you perform.
  2. Write the six characteristics in your diary as headings. Under each, note any passage that shows it, with a reference. Leave a heading empty if nothing fits. Do not force a match.
  3. Under a seventh heading, list what the text contains that the six do not describe.
  4. Note whether the text's account of itself, the emic view, agrees with yours, the etic view. Then repeat with a text from another century and compare.