In the second century of the common era, in the same cities and among the same readers as the Hermetic writers, teachers on the edges of the Christian churches told a darker story about the world. The highest God, they said, did not make it. It was made by a lesser and ignorant power and is ruled by jailers who hold the soul captive, and the only way out is knowledge, in Greek gnosis. Their movements are called Gnosticism. They are the nearest neighbors of the Hermetica, and the comparison shows clearly what is distinctive in the Hermetic way.
In brief
- Gnostic teachers held that the world was made by an ignorant lesser god and ruled by hostile powers, the archons.
- They were known mainly through their enemies until the Nag Hammadi find of 1945, which also contained Hermetic texts.
- The Hermetica share the hope of salvation by knowledge and ascent through the spheres, but most of them call the cosmos beautiful and its maker good.
- The difference is between fleeing the world and transfiguring it, and it matters for practice.
Who the gnostics were
The name covers teachers and groups active from the early second century, mostly in Egypt, Syria and Rome. Basilides taught in Alexandria in the reign of Hadrian. Valentinus, also trained in Alexandria, taught in Rome around the middle of the century and founded the most sophisticated of the schools, whose members saw themselves as a spiritual elite within the churches. Others, whom modern scholars call Sethians because they honored Seth, the third son of Adam, as the ancestor of a chosen race, produced a rich literature of revelations and heavenly journeys.
For centuries these teachers were known almost entirely through their opponents. Irenaeus, bishop of Lyon, wrote his Against Heresies around 180 to expose what he called knowledge falsely so called, and later writers such as Hippolytus and Epiphanius added further reports. They are hostile witnesses. They accused the gnostics of both harsh asceticism and moral license, and must be read with care. But there was little else to read.
The find at Nag Hammadi
In December 1945 farmers digging near the town of Nag Hammadi in Upper Egypt found a jar containing thirteen books in Coptic, one of them only a few leaves. The books had been copied in the fourth century. Who buried them, and why, is uncertain. Most of their fifty or so texts were previously unknown, among them the Secret Book of John, the fullest statement of the Sethian myth.
The sixth book held a surprise. Alongside gnostic works it contained three Hermetic texts: the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth, an initiation dialogue unknown before; a Prayer of Thanksgiving also known in Greek and Latin; and a Coptic version of part of the Asclepius. Whoever collected these books read Hermes and the gnostics together and evidently found them compatible. That does not prove the two teachings were the same, and a close reading shows that they were not. The Hermetic texts are described on our pages on the Hermetic texts and on rebirth.
The gnostic myth
The myths differ, but a common pattern runs through the best known. Beyond everything stands the unknowable Father, the invisible Spirit, so far above being that nothing can properly be said of him. From him comes a series of divine beings called aeons, emanated in pairs, who together make up the fullness, the pleroma, of the divine world. The last of the aeons is Sophia, Wisdom. In the Sethian telling she tries to bring forth offspring on her own, without her partner and without the consent of the Father, and produces a misshapen being who knows nothing of the world above. This is the Demiurge, the craftsman, called in the texts by names such as Yaldabaoth.
Ignorant of his origin, the Demiurge believes himself the only god. He makes the visible cosmos as a poor copy of a fullness he cannot see, and he makes rulers, the archons, to govern it. The archons are set over the planetary spheres, and their government is fate. Together they shape the first human body, but a spark of divine power, which the Demiurge had taken from his mother, passes through him into the human being, so that the creature is greater than its makers. The archons respond by binding it in matter, desire and forgetfulness.
Salvation comes from above. A revealer descends from the fullness, often identified with Christ, to wake the sleeping spark by reminding it who it is and where it came from. This knowledge is not information but recognition, and it saves. At death the awakened soul rises through the spheres, past the archons who try to hold it, and returns to the fullness. In the Valentinian version the Demiurge is less wicked than ignorant, and humanity is divided into spiritual, psychic and material kinds of people, only the first of whom are certain of salvation.
Hermes and the gnostics
Much of this will sound familiar to a reader of the first Hermetic treatise, the Poimandres. There too a primal Human, made in the image of the highest God, descends through the seven spheres and falls into nature. There too the planets are governors whose rule is fate, the human being is double, mortal in body and immortal in mind, and salvation comes through knowledge. There too the soul at death rises through the spheres until it enters the Eighth and passes into God. Earlier scholars counted the Hermetica as gnostic for this reason, and the ascent described on our page on the Hermetic cosmos is close kin to the gnostic journey.
The difference lies in how the texts feel about the world. In the Poimandres the maker of the planetary governors is a second Mind, a craftsman brought forth by the first God and joined with his Word. The governors are not jailers: the rising soul gives back to each the power that belongs to it, and passes. Most treatises praise the cosmos outright as the image of God, a second god, beautiful and good. The Asclepius calls the human being a great wonder, made to care for the earth as well as to worship heaven, and one treatise counts it a misfortune and an impiety to die without children. None of this is gnostic.
Yet the line is not clean. Treatise VI says that the good is found in God alone and that the cosmos is a fullness of evil, and treatise VII calls the body a garment of ignorance, a living death and a tomb we carry about with us. Written by many hands, the Hermetica range on this question from joy to gloom. Think of a spectrum rather than two camps: the most world affirming treatises at one end, the darker ones toward the middle, the gnostic myths at the far end.
| Question | Gnostic myth | Hermetic treatises |
|---|---|---|
| The creator | An ignorant or arrogant lesser god, distinct from the true God | God, or a craftsman Mind that God brings forth; good |
| The cosmos | A flawed copy and a prison | Mostly a beautiful living being, a second god; darker in VI and VII |
| The body | A fetter made by the archons | A garment, at times a hindrance, never the work of an enemy |
| The planets | Archons who guard the way and bind the soul | Governors whose rule is fate; the rising soul returns their powers |
| Salvation | A revealer wakes the spark, which escapes the cosmos | Knowledge of God through teaching, piety and rebirth; becoming divine |
| Ethics | Mostly ascetic withdrawal; an elite of the spiritual | Piety, reverence for the cosmos, care for the earth and family |
Plotinus against the gnostics
The sharpest ancient criticism of the gnostics came not from a bishop but from a pagan philosopher. Plotinus, the founder of Neoplatonism, found gnostics among those who attended his lectures in Rome in the third century, some of them his friends, and they read revelations ascribed to Zoroaster, Zostrianos, Allogenes and others. Texts bearing the last two of those names were found at Nag Hammadi. His treatise against them stands in the Enneads as Against the Gnostics (Enneads II.9).
His argument is a defense of the world. The cosmos is an image of the divine world above it, as fine an image as could be made, and to despise it is to despise its source, since whoever loves a father loves his children too. He mocked people who think themselves children of God and above the heavens while calling the vilest of men their brothers and refusing that name to the sun and stars. And he observed that the gnostics, for all their talk of salvation, had nothing to say about virtue. It does no good, he wrote in substance, to tell people to look to God without teaching them how to look. For Plotinus the way up passed through the beauty of this world, not around it.
The word and its later history
The noun Gnosticism is modern. It was coined in the seventeenth century by the English Platonist Henry More and later stretched to cover almost any movement that ranked knowledge above faith. Some scholars now doubt that it names one thing at all, and prefer narrower labels such as Sethian and Valentinian. On this site the word means the teachers and texts of the second and third centuries described above, and nothing broader.
Two later histories should be kept apart from the ancient one. In the Middle Ages dualist movements such as the Bogomils of the Balkans and the Cathars of southern France also taught that the material world was the work of an evil power. Popular books often call them heirs of the gnostics, but there is no reliable evidence of continuous descent, and similar ideas could arise again from the same scriptures. In the twentieth century Carl Jung read the gnostics as early explorers of the unconscious. In 1916 he privately printed the Seven Sermons to the Dead in the voice of Basilides, and one of the Nag Hammadi books, bought in 1952 and presented to him, bore his name for a time. Through him and through popular books, gnostic themes passed into modern fiction and spirituality, often stripped of their context.
Flight or transfiguration
What should a Hermetic student take from the comparison? First, a distinction. Both traditions agree that human beings are asleep and that knowledge wakes them, a theme taken further on our page on gnosis and awakening. They disagree about what the waking person does next. In the gnostic myth the awakened soul recognizes the world as a prison and seeks to leave it. In the main Hermetic tradition the awakened soul sees the world for the first time as it is, the image of God, and returns to it changed. The first is a way of flight. The second is a way of transfiguration, the one the Emerald Tablet describes when it says that the power is complete only when turned into earth, and that what rises to heaven descends again.
Second, a warning, set out more fully on our page on gnosis: the gnostic sorting of people into spiritual and material kinds is the classic form of a temptation that returns whenever students of the occult begin to call other people sleepers. Contempt is not insight. It is usually a projection of what we refuse to see in ourselves, and the work described under shadow and integration is its remedy. Nor is the body an enemy to be escaped. The Great Work is done in a body, among ordinary people, in an ordinary life, and the sign that it is succeeding is not distance from the world but a greater capacity to love it.